Judicial Precedents & High Court Tracker

CGST Rule 96(10) Export Refund Litigation Tracker

IL

Authoritative Compliance Lead

Last Updated: 20 November 2026
7 min read
Statutory Review Protocol
Verified
Statutory Baseline: Grounded in verbatim Acts & CBDT/CBIC rules.
Judicial Grounding: Validated against High Court precedents.
Assessment Year: Validated for AY 2026-27 (FY 2025-26).

CGST Rule 96(10) Export Refund Litigation Tracker

Statutory Summary and Direct Legal Ratio:
CGST Rule 96(10) was omitted by CBIC via Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax dated October 8, 2024 without a saving clause. In M/s Goodluck India Limited and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors. (SLP (Civil) No. 24550 of 2025, decided August 6, 2026), the Supreme Court held that omitting a subordinate rule without a saving clause extinguishes all pending proceedings, affirming earlier High Court relief in M/s Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India (R/Special Civil Application No. 22519 of 2019). Accepting the judgment via Office Memorandum F. No. CBIC-20010/21/2026-GST (August 24, 2026) and the 57th GST Council recommendation (October 8, 2026), CBIC issued Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated October 26, 2026 clarifying that the omission of Rule 96(10), Rule 89(4A), and Rule 89(4B) operates retrospectively from October 23, 2017.


Executive Overview: The Complete Lifecycle of Rule 96(10)

CGST Rule 96(10) prohibited exporters who imported raw materials under duty-exemption schemes - such as Advance Authorization (AA), Export Oriented Units (EOU), or EPCG - from exporting finished goods on payment of IGST and claiming IGST refunds.

1. The Omission (Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax)

Pursuant to 54th GST Council recommendations, CBIC issued Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax dated October 8, 2024, formally omitting Rule 96(10) (alongside Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B)) from the CGST Rules, 2017. Crucially, the notification was issued without a statutory saving clause.

2. Supreme Court Mandate & 57th GST Council Alignment

On August 6, 2026, the Supreme Court in Goodluck India Limited (SLP (Civil) No. 24550 of 2025) held that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act does not save pending actions under an omitted rule without an express saving clause. CBIC formally accepted this verdict on August 24, 2026 (F. No. CBIC-20010/21/2026-GST), and on October 8, 2026, the 57th GST Council recommended formalizing retrospective omission effective from October 23, 2017.

3. Binding CBIC Clarification (Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST)

Issued under Section 168(1) of the CGST Act on October 26, 2026, Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST (F. No. CBIC-20001/2/2026-GST) instructs all Central and State field formations that the omission of Rule 96(10)—and mutatis mutandis Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B)—applies retrospectively from October 23, 2017 across all pending SCNs, adjudication proceedings, and appeals.


Judicial Scorecard: Rule 96(10) Precedents and Council Decisions

The table below details landmark judicial precedents, official GST Council actions, and exact citations.

DateCourt or ForumCase Details and Exact CitationPositionJudicial History and Appellate StatusOperative Legal Ratio and Holding
2026-11Karnataka High Court (Division Bench)The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax vs. M/s Volvo Group India Private Limited
Writ Appeal No. 1527 of 2026 (T-RES)
2026:KHC:62762-DB (decided 13.11.2026)
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters- 2025-07-21: OIO rejected Rs. 4,38,95,926 IGST export refund (March 2020).
- 2025-12-15: Single Judge (W.P. No. 32359/2025) directed refund.
- 2026-11-13: Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K.S. Hemalekha dismissed Revenue appeal.
Applying Goodluck India Limited (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1523), Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. ((2000) 2 SCC 536), and noting CBIC Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST (26.10.2026), proceedings under omitted Rule 96(10) cannot continue without a saving clause.
2026-10CBIC (GST Policy Wing)Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST
F. No. CBIC-20001/2/2026-GST (dated 26.10.2026)
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters- 2026-08-24: CBIC accepted SC ruling via OM F. No. CBIC-20010/21/2026-GST.
- 2026-10-26: Formal circular issued under Section 168(1).
Clarifies that the omission of Rule 96(10), Rule 89(4A), and Rule 89(4B) operates retrospectively from 23.10.2017 across all pending proceedings.
2026-10GST Council (57th Meeting)Official Recommendation
PIB PRID 2320934
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters- 2026-10-08: Council recommended retrospective omission of Rule 96(10) w.e.f. 23.10.2017.
- Status: Implemented via Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST.
Recommended retrospective omission of Rule 96(10) back to October 23, 2017. All pending SCNs, recoveries, and refund disputes stand statutorily closed without liability.
2026-08Supreme Court of IndiaM/s Goodluck India Limited and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors.
SLP (Civil) No. 24550 of 2025 (decided 06.08.2026)
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters- 2024-10-08: Rule 96(10) omitted via Notification No. 20/2024-CT.
- 2026-08-06: Supreme Court relied on Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. ((2000) 2 SCC 536).
The omission of Rule 96(10) without a saving clause applies to all pending proceedings. GST Council recommendation for prospectivity is advisory and does not bind rule-making authority.
2024-06Gujarat High Court (Division Bench)M/s Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India
R/Special Civil Application No. 22519 of 2019
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters• 2024-06-13: Gujarat High Court held omission without saving clause extinguishes all pending proceedings.
• Status: Directed refund sanction where pre-import conditions caused no revenue loss.
Omission of Rule 96(10) without a saving clause completely obliterates the rule. All pending SCNs, demand orders, and litigation based solely on Rule 96(10) are legally unsustainable and quashed.
2020-10Gujarat High Court (Landmark)Cosmo Films Limited vs. Union of India
R/Special Civil Application No. 15833/2018
[Relief] In Favor of Exporters (Prospective Only)• 2018-10-09: Notification No. 54/2018-CT amended Rule 96(10) retrospectively.
• 2020-10: Gujarat High Court struck down retrospective application.
• Status: Revenue filed SLP before Supreme Court.
Amendments to Rule 96(10) can operate prospectively only (w.e.f. 09.10.2018). Retrospective application to past exports is unconstitutional.
2026-01Supreme Court of IndiaUnion of India vs. Cosmo Films Ltd. and Ors.
SLP (C) No. 9112/2021
[SLP Pending]• 2021: Revenue challenged Gujarat High Court prospectivity ruling.
• 2026-01: Listed before Supreme Court Bench. Court declined to stay High Court relief in active matters.
Apex court examining prospectivity. Exporters protected by High Court orders and executive omission under Notification No. 20/2024-CT.

The Addwrap Packaging and General Clauses Ratio

In M/s Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. (R/Special Civil Application No. 14210/2024), the Gujarat High Court established:

"When a rule is omitted by the executive without appending a saving clause under Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, the rule must be treated as if it had never existed, except as to transactions past and closed. Consequently, all pending proceedings under Rule 96(10) - including unadjudicated Show Cause Notices and pending appeals - lapse immediately."

Statutory Progression & Legal Effect:

  1. Statutory Trigger: Notification No. 20/2024-CT (dated 08.10.2024) omitted Rule 96(10), reinforced by the 57th GST Council Recommendation (operationalized retrospectively via CBIC Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST).
  2. Absence of Saving Clause: No saving clause was preserved under Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897.
  3. Retrospective Obliteration: The omission operates retrospectively from 23.10.2017, treating Rule 96(10) as non-existent on the statute book except for past and closed transactions.
  4. Consequence on Proceedings: All pending unadjudicated Show Cause Notices (SCNs), recovery demands, and open refund disputes stand statutorily extinguished.

Chartered Tax Filing & Advisory

File Your Tax Return with Legal Accuracy

Direct 1-on-1 CA verification of Form 16, AIS, TIS, and capital gains statements. Eliminate notice risks and maximize your legitimate tax savings.


Action Plan for Exporters Facing Rule 96(10) Notices

If your export business is facing an SCN, recovery demand, or appellate dispute under Rule 96(10):

  1. Submit Formal Abatement Application: File an immediate representation before the Adjudicating Authority or Appellate Authority placing on record:
    • CBIC Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated October 26, 2026 (F. No. CBIC-20001/2/2026-GST), binding under Section 168(1), confirming retrospective omission from October 23, 2017 for Rules 96(10), 89(4A), and 89(4B).
    • CBIC Office Memorandum F. No. CBIC-20010/21/2026-GST dated August 24, 2026 and the 57th GST Council Recommendation (PIB PRID 2320934, October 8, 2026).
    • Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax dated October 8, 2024 (omission without saving clause).
    • M/s Goodluck India Ltd. (SLP (Civil) No. 24550 of 2025), M/s Volvo Group India Pvt. Ltd. (2026:KHC:62762-DB), and M/s Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. (R/SCA No. 22519 of 2019).
  2. Plead Total Lack of Statutory Jurisdiction: Argue that following the rule's omission without a saving clause, the department lacks statutory jurisdiction to adjudicate or enforce Rule 96(10) demands.
  3. Submit Proof of Duty Regularization: Where applicable, attach documentation showing that basic customs duty or integrated tax on inputs under Advance Authorization was regularized with applicable interest.
  4. Writ Remedy Under Article 226: If adjudicating authorities decline to drop Rule 96(10) proceedings, approach the jurisdictional High Court seeking quashing of notices citing Addwrap Packaging and the 57th GST Council mandate.

For specialized export refund litigation and High Court writ defense under Rule 96(10), consult the ITRnGST Legal Team.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for updating on legal landscape developments and educational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the current legal status of CGST Rule 96(10)?
Rule 96(10) was omitted via Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax dated October 8, 2024 without a saving clause. Following the Supreme Court ruling in M/s Goodluck India Limited (August 6, 2026) and the 57th GST Council recommendation (October 8, 2026), CBIC issued Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated October 26, 2026 confirming that the omission of Rule 96(10), Rule 89(4A), and Rule 89(4B) operates retrospectively from October 23, 2017.
How does the retrospective omission affect pending Show Cause Notices?
Under Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated October 26, 2026 (implementing Goodluck India Limited and Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd.), the omission of Rule 96(10) without a saving clause operates retrospectively from October 23, 2017. Field formations are instructed to close all pending SCNs, demand orders, and appellate proceedings tied to Rule 96(10).
Can exporters who imported under Advance Authorization claim IGST export refunds?
Yes. Following the omission of Rule 96(10) and judicial rulings in Addwrap Packaging and Cosmo Films, exporters utilizing Advance Authorization, EOU, or EPCG schemes are eligible to export goods on payment of IGST and claim refunds under Rule 96.
Did the Supreme Court stay High Court relief granted to exporters under Rule 96(10)?
No. While Revenue SLPs against High Court rulings on prospectivity (SLP (C) No. 9112/2021) were heard, the Supreme Court consistently declined to interfere with High Court orders quashing Rule 96(10) recovery demands where basic tax was regularized.