Litigation Tracker: GST Portal "Additional Notices" Tab & Ex-Parte Orders
Authoritative Compliance Lead
Litigation Tracker: GST Portal "Additional Notices" Tab & Ex-Parte Orders
Statutory Summary & Direct Legal Ratio:
Uploading Show Cause Notices or Demand Orders exclusively under the obscured portal sub-tab (Services -> User Services -> Additional Notices & Orders) without issuing email or SMS alerts does NOT constitute effective service under Section 169 of the CGST Act, 2017. The Madras High Court (Murugappa HardwaresW.P. No. 14210/2026), Punjab & Haryana High Court (A.S. EnterprisesCWP No. 8112/2026), Rajasthan High Court (Royal MarbleD.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15410/2025), Madhya Pradesh High Court (Vindhya SteelsWrit Petition No. 24102/2025), Telangana High Court (Sri Krishna AgenciesW.P. No. 27812/2025), Calcutta High Court (Raj MetalWPA No. 22104/2025), and Delhi High Court (Bright StarW.P.(C) No. 4812/2025) have quashed ex-parte orders (DRC-07) and bank account attachments (DRC-13) passed under this hidden tab, remanding matters for fresh adjudication.
Executive Overview: The "Hidden Tab" Controversy
A widespread procedural grievance among taxpayers across India is the issuance of ex-parte assessment orders (Form DRC-07) arising from Show Cause Notices uploaded exclusively under a hidden sub-menu on the GST Portal:
GST Portal -> Services -> User Services -> Additional Notices & Orders
The Core Natural Justice Conflict
- The Glitch: Notices uploaded under "Additional Notices & Orders" were separated from the main "Notices & Orders" tab. Crucially, the GSTN portal frequently failed to trigger separate email or SMS alerts to taxpayers.
- The Consequence: Taxpayers remained completely unaware of pending proceedings until departmental officers attached their bank accounts (Form DRC-13) or initiated summary recovery.
- The Statutory Violation: Passing ex-parte demand orders without ensuring actual service of notice or granting a personal hearing violates Section 75(4) and Section 169 of the CGST Act.
Portal Architecture Update: GSTN Advisory of February 5, 2026
Following persistent directives from multiple High Courts, the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) formally dismantled this dual-tab architecture:
- The Merger (February 5, 2026): GSTN issued an official Advisory confirming that the separate "Additional Notices and Orders" tab has been discontinued and merged into the primary "Notices and Orders" tab.
- Unified Access Path: All communications across all GST modules (audit, scrutiny, registration cancellation, DRC-01, DRC-01A, and appeal orders) are now centralized under:
Dashboard -> Services -> User Services -> View Notices and Orders - Legal Implications of the Merger:
- For Past Demands (Pre-February 2026): The merger is purely prospective in technical application. High Court rulings quashing ex-parte orders remain fully effective for any demand passed when the dual-tab architecture obscured communications.
- For Prospective Proceedings (Post-February 2026): Because communications are now in a single, consolidated location, taxpayers can no longer plead ignorance based on the dual-tab defense for newly issued notices. Regular weekly monitoring of the unified tab is mandatory.
Comprehensive High Court Judicial Scorecard: "Additional Notices" Tab
The table below details landmark High Court judgments quashing ex-parte GST demand orders passed due to obscured portal notices across India with exact case citations.
| Date | Court / Forum | Case Details & Exact Citation | Position | Appellate Status & Relief Granted | Operative Legal Ratio & Holding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-11 | High Court of Meghalaya (Division Bench) | B.S. Automobiles vs. The State of Meghalaya and Ors. WP(C) No. 190 of 2026 2026:MLHC:1299-DB (17.11.2026) | [In Favor of Revenue] (4-Week Appeal Liberty) | • 2025-02-27: Section 73 OIO confirmed Rs. 19,90,088 demand after ASMT-10 reply (21.09.2024) and DRC-01 (28.11.2024).• 2026-11-17: Writ dismissed as non-maintainable (delay past 27.06.2025 appeal deadline); 4 weeks granted for Section 107 appeal. | Where petitioner had actual prior knowledge of identical ASMT-10/DRC-01 demand figures and the hearing date yet did not appear or reply, proceedings show substantial compliance with Section 73(1) and no breach of natural justice. |
| 2026-11 | Calcutta High Court | Keshab Joshi vs. The State of West Bengal and Ors. WPA 5907 of 2026 (12.11.2026) | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2025-11-21: Section 107 appeal against FY 2020-21 ex-parte order dismissed on limitation despite 10% pre-deposit u/s 107(6). • 2026-11-12: Justice Smita Das De set aside dismissal; directed merits disposal within 6 weeks and review of bank attachment ( 19.02.2026) and ECL debits (Rs. 3,59,409 and Rs. 1,04,574). | A senior-citizen taxpayer lacking electronic portal literacy who missed notices due to his tax consultant's prolonged illness cannot be left remediless; appellate authority must adjudicate on merits under Section 107(7) and examine coercive recoveries. |
| 2026-10 | CBIC (Adjudication Guidelines) | Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST (26.10.2026) F. No. CBIC-20001/2/2026-GST Para 10.1(vi) | [Binding Departmental Relief] | • 2026-10-26: Issued mandatory master guidelines for personal hearings and speaking orders. • Scope: Applies to all pending adjudication proceedings under CGST Act. | If an adjudicating authority is transferred after a personal hearing is conducted, the successor officer must grant a fresh opportunity of personal hearing before passing a speaking order. |
| 2026-10 | Rajasthan High Court (DB) | M/s Manoj Spares vs. Union of India & Ors. D.B. CWP No. 18521/2026 2026:RJ-JD:45395-DB (05.10.2026) | [In Favor of Revenue] (Limitation Strictness) | • 2026-10-05: Division Bench declined writ intervention against Section 107 appeal rejection. • Ratio: Distinguished valid portal upload from pre-2024 hidden tab disputes. | Once valid upload on the GST portal establishes effective communication, taxpayers cannot routinely invoke writ jurisdiction to bypass the strict Section 107(4) appellate limitation. See Manoj Spares case analysis. |
| 2023-09 | Madras High Court (Foundational Ruling) | East Coast Constructions and Industries Ltd. vs. Asst. Commr. (ST) W.P. No. 26457 of 2023 [2023] 10 Centax 192 (Mad.) | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-09-11: Quashed ex-parte assessment order and remanded for fresh adjudication. • Directives: Directed GSTN and Department to resolve procedural confusion caused by dual tabs. | Introducing a separate "View Additional Notices and Orders" tab under "User Services" without adequate alerts denies reasonable opportunity. Mere hosting in obscure sub-tab does not constitute effective service. |
| 2023-12 | Madras High Court | Tvl. Evershine Industries vs. Asst. Commr. (ST) W.P. No. 35306 of 2023 [2024] 158 taxmann.com 233 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-12-21: Quashed DRC-07 order passed without petitioner knowledge. • Relief: Remanded for fresh hearing subject to 10% pre-deposit. | Where SCN and reminders were placed exclusively under "View Additional Notices" without taxpayer awareness, ex-parte order violates Section 75(4) mandatory hearing mandate. |
| 2023-09 | Madras High Court | Murugesan Jayalakshmi vs. State Tax Officer W.P. No. 25488 of 2023 [2023] 155 taxmann.com 577 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-09-08: Set aside summary demand order; permitted filing of reply. | Failure to check a newly inserted portal sub-menu without email/SMS alert does not justify penalizing assessee without hearing. |
| 2023-12 | Madras High Court | Tvl. Sri Namasivaya Auto Parts vs. State Tax Officer W.P. No. 34783 of 2023 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-12-18: Quashed order-in-original and lifted bank attachment. | Notices hosted exclusively under "Additional Notices" were never brought to knowledge of taxpayer, vitiating assessment proceedings. |
| 2024-05 | Delhi High Court (Landmark) | M/s Ace Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors. W.P.(C) 6758/2024 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2024-05-10: Set aside DRC-07 order; restored right to file reply and attend hearing. | Uploading statutory notices solely under "Additional Notices" tab is not easily accessible and does not satisfy proper service requirements under Section 169. |
| 2023-02 | Delhi High Court | Singla Exports vs. Commr. of CGST W.P.(C) 1255/2023 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-02-01: Quashed ex-parte demand; directed opportunity of personal hearing. | Technical availability on portal sub-tab cannot substitute for actual opportunity of hearing guaranteed under Section 75(4). |
| 2024-05 | Madhya Pradesh High Court | Light Group vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. Writ Petition No. 11572 of 2024 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2024-05-03: Set aside ex-parte demand order; remanded for fresh adjudication. | Uploading notices solely on hidden sub-tab without exploring RPAD or email violates natural justice principles under Section 169. |
| 2023-07 | Calcutta High Court | Ramkrishna Forgings Ltd. vs. State of West Bengal WPA 15418 of 2023 | [Relief] In Favor of Taxpayer | • 2023-07-18: Quashed demand order passed without real opportunity of hearing. | Department must ensure effective intimation before passing adverse orders leading to coercive recovery. |
Key Legal Principles Established by High Courts
Portal Upload Alone ≠ Effective Service -> Secondary Service (Section 169) Required -> Natural Justice Prevails
- Section 169 (Modes of Service): Section 169 of the CGST Act lists multiple modes of service (including email, registered post, and portal). High Courts hold that if pre-2024 hidden-tab portal uploads yield zero response, officers must use registered post or email to ensure actual notice; however, under newer post-fix uploads, Rajasthan High Court in Manoj Spares (
2026:RJ-JD:45395-DB) cautioned that portal communication triggers strict Section 107(4) limitation where effective service is established. - Section 75(4) Mandatory Hearing and Officer Transfer Rule: Personal hearing is statutorily mandatory whenever an adverse tax or penalty order is contemplated. Under Para 10.1(vi) of CBIC Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST (
26.10.2026), even where a personal hearing took place earlier, a successor officer upon transfer must grant a fresh hearing before passing a speaking order. Review our CBIC Circular 258 guidelines guide for complete procedural checks. - Limitation Period Defense: Buried portal notices in the legacy Additional Notices tab without separate communication do not start the limitation period clock against an unsuspecting taxpayer, though regular portal monitoring remains critical to avoid Section 107(4) bars. Crucially, the Meghalaya High Court in B.S. Automobiles (
2026:MLHC:1299-DB) rejected a writ challenge where the taxpayer knew of the DRC-01 demand and hearing date (while granting four weeks for statutory appeal), whereas the Calcutta High Court in Keshab Joshi (WPA 5907 of 2026) set aside an appellate limitation dismissal where a senior citizen lacked electronic portal expertise and his tax consultant suffered prolonged illness.
Action Plan for Taxpayers Facing Ex-Parte Portal Orders
If your business discovers an ex-parte GST order (Form DRC-07) or bank account attachment (Form DRC-13) passed via the "Additional Notices" tab:
- Download Portal History & Audit Trail: Take screenshots proving the notice was placed under Services -> User Services -> Additional Notices & Orders and note the absence of email/SMS alerts.
- File Writ Petition under Article 226: Approach the High Court seeking quashing of the ex-parte order on grounds of natural justice violation and lack of personal hearing under Section 75(4).
- Cite High Court Precedents and CBIC Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST: Rely on Para 10.1(vi) of CBIC Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST (
26.10.2026) where the officer changed prior to passing the order, alongside East Coast Constructions (W.P. No. 26457 of 2023), Ace Cardiopathy Solutions (W.P.(C) 6758/2024), Tvl. Evershine Industries (W.P. No. 35306 of 2023), Murugesan Jayalakshmi (W.P. No. 25488 of 2023), and Light Group (Writ Petition No. 11572 of 2024), while distinguishing Manoj Spares (2026:RJ-JD:45395-DB) where legacy portal tab concealment occurred. - Offer Conditional Pre-Deposit: Express willingness to deposit 10% of disputed tax to demonstrate bona fide intent for a fresh hearing.
For expert representation challenging ex-parte GST portal orders and lifting DRC-13 bank attachments, consult the ITRnGST Legal Team.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for updating on legal landscape developments and educational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice.
Received a Tax Notice or SCN on this Matter?
Our specialized tax advocates and CAs draft factual, jurisprudence-backed replies with High Court & Supreme Court precedents to protect your rights and drop unwarranted demands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are High Courts quashing GST assessment orders passed under the "Additional Notices & Orders" tab?
Does uploading a notice on the "Additional Notices" sub-tab trigger the limitation clock for filing an appeal?
How have Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh High Courts ruled on hidden portal notices?
What should a taxpayer do if their bank account is attached due to an ex-parte order from the Additional Notices tab?
Explore More JUDICIAL TRACKER Guides
Bunching of GST Show Cause Notices Tracker
Track High Court split rulings, 57th GST Council SCN reforms, Section 74A transition, and Supreme Court status on bunching multi-year GST notices.
Litigation Tracker: Validity of Section 168A GST Limitation Notifications
Track High Court rulings and Supreme Court SLP status on the constitutional validity of Section 168A notifications (56/2023 dated 28.12.2023, 09/2023 dated 31.03.2023) extending Section 73 time limits for FY 2017-18, 2018-19, and 2019-20.
GSTAT Appeals & Statutory Jurisdiction: Comprehensive Procedural Guide (2026)
Master the statutory framework for filing GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) appeals under Section 112. Learn limitation period rules, portal token generation, bench jurisdiction, and automatic stay of recovery.
Curated based on your reading interest
Browse All